No to 5 States’ Rwanda Deportation Deal!
EUROPEAN LEFT WORKING GROUP ON MIGRATION POLICY
Europe cannot turn human rights into a bargaining chip.
The project for a deportation center in Rwanda promoted by five European governments, as well as the centers established by Italy in Albania, represent the next step in Europe’s restrictive migration policy. Migration management cannot be based on deportation and violations of fundamental rights.
The decision announced on November 16 by Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece, and the Netherlands to initiate a joint process with the Rwandan government to establish a repatriation center outside the borders of the European Union represents further escalation in European migration policies. The CEAS Reform has created the basis for so called Rwanda Deals and the externalisation of asylum procedures while the new Return Regulation provides the missing piece of the puzzle, providing an framework for estabilishing deportation centers and further institutionalising the logic of outsourcing responsibility.

With this project, the five governments intend to transfer migrant persons subject to return orders to Rwanda, even when they have no ties to that country. An initiative that should become operational in 2027 and that raises very serious questions about the protection of fundamental rights, legal guarantees, and respect for international law. This concerns the deadly effect of the approval of the Immigration and Asylum Pact as well as the Return Regulation. Deportations under the new Return Regulation are currently unlawful, but this does not prevent governments from planning them. We are increasingly witnessing goverments disregarding their legal and human rights obligations. This normalisation of law breaches sets the basis for the far right realising their goals on the european level. As European Left we fight against this developments in the broader process of autoritarian restructuring.
The European Left condemns this drift. Europe cannot shirk its responsibilities by transferring people elsewhere, nor can it delegate the implementation of its expulsion policies to third countries. The protection of human rights cannot be subordinated to deterrence and border control objectives.
It is particularly serious that this announcement reaches Vienna just as the Vienna Migration Conference is taking place, attended by representatives of the involved governments and the Rwandan Minister of the Interior. While international cooperation and migration governance are being discussed, a model based on outsourcing returns and transforming third countries into instruments of European border policies is being consolidated.
We cannot ignore, moreover, the critical issues related to the human rights situation in Rwanda, which already emerged in the failure of the previous British project, declared illegitimate by the UK Supreme Court in 2023. The Council of Europe has also expressed strong concerns about the so-called “return hubs,” questioning their legitimacy, high cost, and compatibility with the protection of fundamental rights and the judicial role of EU member states. While they tell us there is no money for schools, health care and poverty eviation, they want to spend millions on illegal deportation centers.
This policy does not address the causes of migration, does not fight trafficking networks, and does not build security. Instead, it fuels a race to the bottom among European governments, which chase the right and far right on the ground of repression, normalizing languages and policies.
The European Left supports a radical alternative: legal and secure routes to Europe for job search and humanitarian protection requests, full respect for the subjective right to asylum and the principle of non-refoulement, solidarity and shared responsibility among Member States, reception and inclusion policies, and international cooperation based on social justice and mutual respect.
We ask European governments to stop this project and the institutions of the European Union not to endorse a model that risks emptying the fundamental guarantees of European and international law of meaning.
Human rights do not stop at European borders. And the dignity of people is not a negotiable point but one where Europe must mark a positive break with the past.